
A gray catbird perches on a branch in New England.
I was focused on the right side of the trail as I saw a white-throated sparrow dart into the thick brush. With it being early in “white-throated sparrow and junco season,” I wanted to find the bird because it’s been several months since I’ve seen them. By the middle of winter, I will have seen so many that a lone sparrow diving into the brush will hardly give me pause.
Suddenly, I heard a familiar sound coming from the thick brush on the left side of the trail. In the summer, I would have recognized the sound immediately because it is a common sound of summer. On this cool November day, however, it took a second or two to recognize it as the namesake call of a gray catbird. Out of place or not, hearing the “mew’ sound was exciting enough for me to abandon my search for that white-throated sparrow and turn my attention to finding the catbird.
Sure enough, there it was, moving among the thin branches of a leafless bush. It never came out into the open, but I watched it jump around the branches for a few minutes before it dove into the thick understory.
It was not the first time I had seen a catbird along this trail well later in the year than it should have been hanging around. A few years ago, two catbirds stayed all winter along this trail.
Further down the trail, I saw a handful of juncos on the ground along the left side of the trail. I watched through binoculars and saw the birds jump into the woods. They remained close to the trail and were not as shy as the white-throated sparrow. They may have left the trail, but they remained nearby in the woods as I walked past.
As I walked past and kept an eye on the juncos, I heard another familiar sound on the opposite side of the trail. I recognized this one immediately because I had heard it a week or two earlier. Still, I was surprised to hear the “chewink” or “tow-hee” call of an eastern towhee, which is also such a familiar sound in the spring and summer.
I stopped my walk abruptly and slowly approached the spot where I heard the sound. Within seconds, not one or two, but three male eastern towhees popped up from the ground and perched in a nearby small tree to observe the large creature standing in the middle of the trail. Satisfied that the creature was harmless, they soon disappeared into the thick understory again.
White-throated sparrows and juncos are common late fall and winter birds in New England. Catbirds and towhees are common spring and summer birds in New England. It was a good reminder that birds don’t always fit nicely into categories and that referring to some of them as “winter birds” or “summer birds” doesn’t always work.
Like many things with birds, labels are often just guides, as there are many exceptions to the rules.

















