Deceptive commercial featuring birds (video has returned)

Update on Wednesday, Aug. 26: the video had disappeared from this post. For now anyway, it’s back.)

Birds and bird songs are often misrepresented in movies, TV shows and commercials. An eagle may fly overhead and the sound of a hawk will be played. Often you’ll hear the call of the loon, but the scene in the movie is taking place in an area hundreds (or even thousands) of miles from where the nearest loon would be. That one happens a lot. Of course, we all remember the golf tournament when the TV producers played birdsongs over the golf “action” of birds that weren’t actually there.

I noticed another bird faux pas in a commercial that is out now. The Verizon commercial with the “magnificent geese” that states “Come home for a better network,” features a flock of geese flying and feeding. At one point the commercial zooms in for a closeup on one of the geese.

The implication is that they are following a single flock of geese. At least that’s how I interpret the commercial. The problem is that they show two different species of goose. The vast majority of the commercial features a handsome goose species that I honestly can not identify. It is not a goose that is found in the U.S. _ at least not regularly.  But two briefs clips, including the close up, feature a Canada Goose. If the intention was to show multiple flocks, then the commercial is fine. If it was intended to follow one “suffering” flock, which I think it was, they tried to pull one over on us.

I know, no big deal in the grand scheme of life, but figured I’d point it out anyway. Thanks for checking out http://www.birdsofnewengland.com

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “Deceptive commercial featuring birds (video has returned)

  1. Given their aggressive nature, ubiquity, and plentiful droppings, I find it hard to sympathize with Canada geese under any circumstance. If I could guarantee them poor cell phone reception, I would do so.

    Not what you were justly complaining about. But a pet peeve. I suppose I shouldn’t hold a grudge against wildlife, seeing how much humans have done to them . . . but I make a few exceptions!

    Like

  2. You are not alone! I’ve been confounded by this commercial since it first aired as well. I thought I was missing the point of the commercial, like one species of goose is smarter than another, but I don’t think so… Just confusing.

    Like

  3. The geese in the deceptive commercial are Branta leucopsis. In english they are Barnacle geese, and in spanish they are Barnaclas cariblancas. I just moved here from Spain, and for me they are more common than other birds I’m finding here. — Via email from Felix

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s